Memories of the
Edgewood Campus of the University of KwaZulu-Natal.
The book mentioned above is in the library of the University
of KwaZulu-Natal. It describes the transition from a whites-only institution to
one fully non-racial. It is written from the points of view of persons working
at a transforming college of education that was absorbed into a South African university
as apartheid was dismantled.
In a sense it is a story repeated in many other South
African institutions striving to achieve a non-racial future for the country. Some
staff embraced the idea of transition, many did not. The book will be of use to
anyone, anywhere in the world, engaged with the transformation of an
institution with a racially-defined ethos to a fully integrated, non-racial,
multicultural entity.
The present post appeared largely unchanged as the chapter Recollections
of Edgewood. Alex Coutts 1970-1993.
Please bear with me as I romp through the description of a
mis-spent youth, which might come across as a poor start for a teaching-college
educator. I thoroughly disliked my early schooling because the experience often
scared the wits out of me. Especially when quite small, I found most teachers
to be threatening creatures. My father died when I was seven, and with my
mother working through long days as a bank clerk, I had little parental
guidance in matters educational.
Later at the Northlands Boys High School (now Northwood) in
Durban, I settled down a bit, but at that stage of life still couldn’t see the
point of education. I accordingly spent many happy hours body surfing amidst
the occasional shark in ominously discoloured waters off the Durban North
beaches, when my time could have been spent better by my studying for exams. It
was not a good start for someone who later entered teacher education as a
profession.
Having done a few modest sporting performances at school, I
entered the Durban Teachers’ Training College (Dokkies) where I enjoyed
Physical Education and did well in it. I later passed the specialist course in
Physical Education with distinction at the Paarl Teachers’ Training College,
and went on to teach the subject at Grosvenor Boys High School.
During a break in career prior to joining the Edgewood College
community, I decided to get away from South African’s narrow social and
political confines to see the wider world. I wanted to gain experience in
self-dependence; to see if I could manage on my own. It’s of course something
many young people do.
There followed a venture in deep-sea yachting which
terminated when I left the vessel at Ascension Island in the mid-Atlantic. This
followed an incident with the McCormac Cape, a freighter whose captain was
docking her late at night in the presence of our small, intrusive yacht that
had somehow wandered into the freighter anchorage. After this incident was
settled, the yacht sailed on. I stayed put.
While on the island I worked for Gunn Plumbing of Miami for
several months as a labourer. One of the more memorable incidents was a strike
that turned nasty and culminated in injuries to two African-American workers
and the pay-off of union members by a boss with a loaded revolver on his desk.
A period of teaching in Inner London schools followed. I
then embarked on a six -week hitch-hike across North Africa sipping tea or coffee
with the Bedouin and sleeping in the bitterly cold winter desert. My stores of
experience were growing.
I also endured a harrowing week at Aberfan, assisting the
mortician during the coal-mining disaster of November 1967. We worked in the small
Barthol Chapel building which had been turned into a mortuary. Our team met the
Queen and Prince Philip. More indelibly memorable yet, I was present when
parents entered the small chapel to identify the clothing, possessions or
bodies of their children. Many hurled oaths at the Coal Board and broke down in
tears. At the age of twenty-four I was not prepared psychologically for the
experience. The memories proved enduring.
Returning to South Africa, I joined the staff at Northlands
Boys High School in Durban. The opulent socio-economic status of many parents
meant that they could afford private swimming coaches and so our team did well
over many years, while athletics kept up its long-standing tradition at the
school. This implied winning competitions regularly.
Having done a reasonable job at Northlands, I applied for
the job of lecturer in Physical Education at Edgewood College. I arrived as a bewildered
youth, experienced in some of the more esoteric and even brutal experiences of
life, but not particularly suited to the refinements of Academe.
I brought to the job a tinge of macho, a distrust of
memorisation as the central pillar of education, a mind open to the
non-racialism of many overseas countries and a sense of independence in thought
and action picked up during travels through more than forty countries.
Throughout, I had paid my own way and learnt that the main instrument in achievement
was my own hard effort coupled to such integrity, knowledge and skills as I had
garnered.
On arrival at Edgewood, I was met by strangers. It was a world
different to anything previously experienced. During the 1970’s, the College
was in its infancy, having moved to Pinetown from a previous Durban campus. The
first students were all women.
The popular Eric Edminson, deeply experienced in primary
schooling, headed the staff. A few days
after arrival, he gave me the best advice I ever received from anyone. “Think
things through and look at all the consequences, then if you have a choice,
rather be kind,” he said. “Be kind”.
Eric Edminson was supported by the awesome Sylvia Vietzen (History),
and equally impressive Cynthia Scott (English language), Ailsa Mumby (Mathematics),
Ingrid Machin (History), Rosemary Miles-Cadmin (English), Jill Kelsall
(Religious Studies) and one or two others of equal eminence. I mean no cynicism
here; for a callow youth these teaching academics brought an aura of
intelligence and dignity that led to one conclusion; select your reference
characters well, and learn from them. With a need to accommodate male students,
Messrs Ken Tebbutt (Handcraft), Harry Getliffe (Physical science) and Gordon
Morton (Geography) were appointed in due course.
In those days, a frontier spirit prevailed as the college
buildings were completed. It was fuelled by the noise of frogs at night (an
obsessive talking point for some) and the occasional discharge of dynamite when
protruding rocks were to be removed. For someone who had hitched the coast of
North Africa, bathed with whales on a yacht somewhere in the South Atlantic Ocean,
and watched the Israeli army in action on their border with Jordan, I couldn’t
quite catch the prevailing spirit. It was all so terribly civilized! And if this was a frontier, a frontier to
where? And who lay beyond it?
The staffroom dynamics were interesting. In my naive view,
status was determined by proximity to the tea things. The staff members of the
most highly regarded subjects were in closest proximity, with a long chain of
status down to the ‘practicals’ where I seated myself respectfully.
Language was especially interesting, with second language experiencing
refugee status in a predominantly English-speaking college. They were seated a
long way from such critical survival resources as tea and coffee. I noted that,
when we moved to our grand new staffroom a year or two later, the
second-language department had seated themselves close to the urn and refused
to budge. Main language took to the opposing corner, gloves off and
glowering.
But, lest I give the impression that departments were
habitually at war, I must hasten to add that usually everyone got along fine. During
the twenty or so years I spent at Edgewood, apart from understandable intrigues
and tiffs here and there, the staff members were remarkably combined in their
social interactions and common pursuit of excellence. Many members became my firm
friends.
There were many remarkable and engaging characters. Our new
rector, Professor Andre le Roux, became known for his brilliant, humorous and
athletic public speeches and presentations. I say athletic because Andre was
known for his remarkable agility in bobbing up and down with sheer excitement
as he regaled us with educational insights, anecdotes, homilies and missives.
One could establish the import of a speech quite accurately by recording the
height to which his heels left the stage floor. Andre established a firm
leadership based on a brilliant mind, wide knowledge of many things, basically
compassionate nature and insistence that Edgewood was to become a family to all
who operated there. It was clear that he had distinct visions of a non-racial
future.
I also recall Gordon Morton. His love of Geography (how I
had relied on his textbook Man’s environment years earlier while at
school!) was only exceeded by his love of motor bikes. There was also Rosemary
Miles-Cadman, known for her exceptional intellect, Cynthia Scott who was a leading
academic but also known for her compassionate care for the college cats, for
whose benefit she solicited funds (we called it putting something in the kitty).
Jan Forbes was well reputed for her creative dancing, Hugh Thompson for his
brilliant play productions, and Brian Reid for his insightful, Catholic (with a
capital C) views on History. Brian trained later at the Beda in France for the
Catholic priesthood.
There are so many others, united in the quest to maintain
Edgewood as a centre of excellence. I plodded on steadily, establishing
Physical Education as a component of the broader curriculum, editing The Natal
Physical Educator, and working to transform the subject from a rather limited
physical training, so prevalent during the post-war years, into something
thoroughly grounded in education. This implied giving full vent to a
participant’s cognitive, emotional, social, health, psycho-motor and knowledge
capacities. In due course Jan Forbes and Bob Rottcher took the work forward
brilliantly as I moved more deeply into administration and general education.
I was asked to Head a range of subjects, and Physical Education,
Art, Handcrafts, Speech and Drama, Needlework, Health Education, Electrical Technika,
Electronic Technika, Technical Drawing, Computer Studies and Business Economics
were part of what became known as ‘Alexander’s empire’.
Darryl Houghton was so successful as senior lecturer in Art
that he became subject adviser. Carolyn Higgs and Lorna Shadwell ran Speech and
Drama very capably, while Mike O’Neill did a fine job with the Technical
subjects. Ken Tebbutt managed handcrafts creatively, ensuring that Saturday
‘handcraft fairs’ became a regular feature of college life. My main job was to
assist with critical administrative jobs while ensuring that my own lack of
experience in some of these subjects didn’t destroy the natural capability and
creativity of the specialist staff. It was a great learning experience.
I also served on the College Council, was Secretary to Senate,
managed Practical Teaching, organised or helped organise conferences, served as
college examinations officer, ran the so-called Civil Defence programme,
managed the Grounds and Buildings Committee and supervised the residences. At
one time or another I was on sixteen committees and chaired six. So I kept out
of mischief.
Having entered the college with two teaching diplomas it was
clear to me that I was formally under qualified, so over the years I found time
(often two o’clock in the morning, and most weekends) to do a B.A., B. Ed.,
Masters and D.Ed. Not being sure of the first doctorate’s value, I did a
second. This was a D. Phil. Having struggled at school, I found these degrees
increasingly easy with practice and maturity. I funded them myself, with no
financial sources other than my salary. There was a measure of pride in doing
that.
The second doctorate enjoyed the encouragement of the
rector, Prof Andre le Roux. He was engaged with the Council of Rectors and
Deans of KwaZulu-Natal (CORDTEK) initiative. It was an endeavour to draw
together rectors and deans of universities and colleges, to establish a closer
symbiotic relationship on an equitable, non-racial basis.
My D. Phil. study was based a four-year longitudinal study
of the New Era Schools Trust, an early attempt to explore strategies for
implementing a system of non-racial schooling in South Africa. The idea had
incubated for years. I understand that my study was the first of its kind in
South Africa to explore non-racial schooling. Titled An exploratory Study of the New Era Schools Trust, it was
done in 1989 through the University of Natal (now KwaZulu-Natal). It traced the
development of a system of non-racial schooling that could be a model to guide future
endeavours at the national level.
It investigated such concepts as race, ethnicity and
socio-economic class. As a result, Marxist theory was brought into the Bachelor
of Primary Education classes, which I taught.
Although I personally found flaws with the Marxian analysis, Marx helped
to sensitize me further to the travails of the impoverished and disadvantaged
in South Africa. Thereafter, there was a rapid awakening.
Whilst doing the doctorate and after its completion, during
the 1980s I embarked on a series of perhaps sixty public addresses throughout KwaZulu-Natal
and (occasionally) Gauteng. It was an attempt to convince educators in schools to
brave the emerging new world and become accepting of transition to a modern
non-racial democracy. It involved the dissemination of strategies for
transformation that would lead to a more socially, economically and politically
just society.
Probably the most interesting presentation was done at an
educational institution in Dundee, while apartheid was still fully in force.
After a long drive, I arrived to find a considerable audience, prepared my
slides and engaged with those present. I explained the evolving historical
context as best I could while exploring strategies to accommodate cultures
equitably as a foundation for shifting to a new non-racial dispensation.
And then, whilst in
full flight I noticed (one could hardly ignore them) a phalanx of fourteen
brown-shirted men striding into the hall. They sat down as a tight group. Their
shoulder insignia were those of the AWB. Grim faced and tense, at question time
they rose as one man and distributed leaflets warning of sex across the racial
lines, negative happenings in other countries and the demise of white
privilege.
Their questions were direct and probing. This lead me to
explain that, as far as I was informed the term kaffir (kafir) was derived from
the Arabic word for unbeliever. Did they want to discuss religion? I asked. To
their credit there were no direct threats or aggressive behaviour, but it did
alert me to the prospect of difficult times ahead for us all. I saw them as
ordinary people whose upbringing and political views were radically different
to my own.
I found the doctoral studies through the University of Natal
particularly helpful as Edgewood College began to accommodate the staff and
students of Bechet College, which was being closed. We also took in an initial intake of several
hundred African students. The transition
went as well as such things can, when one takes our benighted history and
socio-economic disparities into account. The Bechet staff, led by Lawrence
Samuels, was magnanimous in coming from their previously ‘secure’ home to adapt
to an alien environment.
Regarding the students, we had to manage matters as fairly
and equitably as we could, including their understandable anger at the
disparity in loans occasioned by Edgewood moving too quickly, ahead of the
state’s capacity to catch up with enabling legislation. The College had
summarily ‘jumped the gun’. White students got R4500 yearly, Coloured students
R2800 and Africans R2200. The figures were the cause of enduring distress.
We had cultural differences to accommodate, also allegations
of discrimination levelled at the house committee members, accusations of
academic bias and much more. But, none of it was in any way as intense as one
might have anticipated, and the newcomers to the campus as well as the existing
community behaved with considerable decorum and restraint.
The Doctorate also no doubt helped my wife Memory and me when
we first took on and raised four abandoned Zulu children as our own progeny. There
were eventually fourteen, albeit at different times. One has lived with us for
twenty-odd years, others for lesser times. For more than thirty years they have
been our sons and daughters.
As each became capable of earning a living, so the next
arrived. Several went through schooling under our care and financing, then
proceeded to higher education. Three have degrees, and four others have
diplomas achieved or pending. One has been ordained a Catholic priest. It was
all funded from our educator salaries. But we, arguably, have been enriched
more than they.
Looking back, the most difficult task I had as vice-rector
occurred in the early 1990s while Prof le Roux was in the Drakensberg foothills
attending a conference. As usual, I was asked to assume responsibility for the
College for a few days. At about 5 p.m. on the first day, just after arriving
home, I received a call from a residence staff member warning of a vehicle
accident involving some of our black students who were returning from our
College to their University residences.
Unsure of what was happening, I drove to the casualty department of the King
Edward V111hospital, closest to the accident site. My actions were based on a simple
assumption.
Our students were there, bloodied and mainly unrecognisable.
I comforted them as best I could, consoled the parents and phoned Prof. le Roux.
I learnt that the driver had died and a student had been injured critically. He
was not expected to survive without serious brain damage. On the following
morning it was necessary to brief Mr Attie Ohlmesdahl, then director of
education, Prof Piet Booysen, vice chancellor and principal of the University
of Natal and Prof Berndene Nel, Dean of the faculty of Education.
A sorrowful memorial service was thereafter held in the
Margaret Martin Theatre at Edgewood. It was lightened only slightly by the
tributes of various members of staff and beautiful, if mournful, singing of the
assembled throng. The week that followed was an understandably tough one. It
culminated in the death of the injured student who had suffered head injuries
and brought tangible sadness that seemed to touch all staff, black and white.
The journey through Edgewood over twenty years was a daily
educative experience. I feel privileged to have made superb friends
irrespective of their race or ethnicity and to have served there. I look on the
experience largely with affection, and trust that the present staff will strive
constantly to exceed what we achieved in the service of the children of
KwaZulu-Natal.
No race is free of racist behaviour to others. More than
ever, South Africans need integrity, service orientation, generosity of spirit,
tolerance and mutual respect if we are to progress. Only then can we claim to
be a light-infused ‘rainbow nation’.
Hello Dr Coutts
ReplyDeleteDo you remember whether Gordon Morton began teaching in 1969 with you. Im writing a chapter on geography at Edgewood campus and would love any information Geography related. my email is manik@ukzn.ac.za
Hello Alex. I so enjoyed reminiscing as I read your eloquent account of the ECE years up until 1993. Do you remember the Zulu Department? It has no feature here and I wondered what disqualified it for mention - it was quite an innovation when I started the department in 1982 and my being housed in the English and then later the Afrikaans wings of offices must have been rather amusing to many. Hope something of that innovation at ECE can be reflected. Joan (ex Thomas)
ReplyDelete